The Evening Replay

Replaying a solved puzzle at night is a different exercise than solving it in the morning.

A solve is a first draft. The evening replay is the edit, and it uses a completely different kind of attention. In the morning the goal is to get to the target. In the evening the goal is to understand why the route worked and whether a better one existed.

The replay should not be a re-solve. Looking at the finished route and annotating it is more useful than resetting the puzzle and trying again, because resetting erases the reasoning that produced the route. Read the first rung and ask whether it was forced. Read the middle and ask whether a pivot was named or merely stumbled into. Read the end and ask whether it was planned or found.

Two or three minutes is enough. The output is usually one sentence, and that sentence goes in the journal. The important part is that it is written at low energy, because low-energy review tends to be honest rather than flattering.

Over a month the replays build a picture of recurring weaknesses that a same-day review cannot see, because the same think happens too fast to notice while the puzzle is fresh.

The evening slot is also a good use of the time when the daily has already been solved and the puzzle tab is still open. The unlimited mode fills the gap if the replay suggests a route worth testing, and play unlimited rounds make a promising pivot repeatable on the spot. Ten minutes of replay is worth more than an hour of extra solves.

The replay also gives the daily puzzle a second value. A solved puzzle is normally discarded, and a discarded puzzle teaches exactly once. A replayed puzzle teaches twice, which is the highest return available from a five-minute investment in a habit like this.